Small Business Saturday 2026 lands on November 28, and the early read is good news for independent shops: in a survey American Express released on November 12, 88% of U.S. consumers said they are likely to shop at small businesses this holiday season, the highest level the company has recorded since 2012. I’d take that number seriously, but not literally. Intent is cheap. What turns it into revenue is whether shoppers can find you, trust you, and swallow your prices, and the same research, read alongside two other surveys out this fall, says all three are harder than the headline suggests.
The headline number is real, but it’s a survey
The figures come from the 2026 Shop Small Impact Study, which Amex commissioned from the consultancy Teneo. The consumer half polled 1,008 U.S. adults online between September 9 and 11, weighted to Census figures. The business half surveyed 503 owners and managers of non-franchise businesses with 2 to 99 employees and a physical location in retail, restaurants and hospitality, personal services, or arts and recreation.
Two things are worth keeping in mind. First, Amex created Small Business Saturday in 2010 and has a clear interest in strong turnout, since it processes the card swipes. Second, “likely to shop small” is a statement about a feeling in September, not a receipt in December. Neither point makes the data wrong. Both are reasons to treat it as a mood reading rather than a sales forecast.
The mood is warm. According to Amex, 78% of consumers say small businesses are essential to their communities, 72% shop small to find memorable gifts, and 70% enjoy discovering new small businesses during the holidays.
Discovery still runs on word of mouth
The most useful finding in the study isn’t the 88%. It’s how shoppers say they find the businesses they visit: recommendations from friends and family (65%), customer reviews (45%), and social media posts (39%).
That ranking should shape where an owner spends the next ten days. Paid advertising isn’t in the top three. Two of the top three channels are other people talking about you, which means the cheapest, highest-return move is to ask your best customers to say something out loud, in person, on a review site or on their own feeds.
Reviews carry a catch. Bruce Dugan has argued that a perfect rating reads as a lie to many shoppers, and I agree. A steady stream of recent, specific reviews, including a few honest four-stars, does more work than a pristine 5.0 that nobody believes.
Owners are trying new things, including AI
On the owner side, Amex reports that 96% are using new strategies to prepare for the season and 90% expect to use AI tools during the holidays, for marketing, operations, and personalization. Seventy percent say holiday spending will affect their ability to grow in 2027, so the stakes are not abstract.
I’m skeptical that 90% of small shops will use AI in any meaningful way between now and New Year’s. “Expect to use” covers everything from drafting an Instagram caption to rebuilding an inventory system. The useful version is narrow: let a tool draft product descriptions, holiday emails, and review replies, then have a human who knows the customers edit them. The gap, as other surveys have found, is training, not tools.
Prices are the pressure point
Here is where the cheerful survey meets the less cheerful one. The National Federation of Independent Business’s October Small Business Economic Trends report put its Optimism Index at 97.8, down 0.1 points and just under its 53-year average of 98.0. A seasonally adjusted net 37% of owners plan to raise prices in the next three months, up six points and the highest since July 2022. Taxes jumped to 21% as owners’ single most important problem, the highest reading since May 2021, while labor quality remained on top at 25%.
Shoppers have noticed. A QuickBooks holiday survey, as reported by Self-Employed, found that only 9% of shoppers view small-business price increases as fully justified, even as 89% say supporting small firms over big retailers matters to them. That is the tension of this season in two numbers: people want to shop small, and they don’t love paying more to do it.
The temptation is to answer with a deep discount on November 28. I’d be careful. Heavy markdowns can teach customers to wait for the next one, and a small shop has less margin to give away than a big-box chain. Bundles, gift-with-purchase offers and gift cards that pull a second visit into January protect margin better than a flat percentage off.
What I’d do before November 28
- Ask for the referral. Tell regulars you’re counting on them, and make it easy to share: a card at the register, a post they can repost.
- Refresh your reviews. Reply to recent ones and ask satisfied customers this week, while the season is fresh.
- Get on the map. Amex offers free Shop Small signage and a Shop Small Map listing; both cost nothing but a few minutes.
- Price with a story. If you’ve raised prices, say why. Shoppers forgive increases they understand more readily than ones that just appear.
- Plan the January visit. The real prize, by Amex’s own framing, is the relationship. Eighty percent of owners told Amex the day can build ties that last beyond the holidays.
If your storefront is mostly online, the same rules apply to your product pages. It’s worth checking that your e-commerce platform can handle a gift-card promotion before the weekend, not during it. Restaurants should lean on branding that gives regulars something to talk about.
What others are saying
The broader season looks solid. The National Retail Federation forecasts November and December retail sales will grow 4.2% over 2025 to $1.013 trillion, faster than last year’s 3.1%. Intuit’s QuickBooks survey, also sponsor-produced, projects shoppers will spend about $118 billion at small businesses, up 8.3%, with small firms capturing a larger share of holiday budgets than in recent years.
Amex’s chief marketing officer, Elizabeth Rutledge, framed the company’s goal as trying to “turn that holiday enthusiasm into lasting relationships.” That is the right goal, and owners can pursue it without anyone’s permission.
The verdict
The demand signal for Small Business Saturday 2026 is the strongest Amex has measured in more than a decade, and the wider retail forecast backs it up. But goodwill is not a business plan. Shoppers find small businesses through people they trust; they are wary of higher prices, and owners are squeezed by taxes and costs. The shops that win November 28 will be the ones that make it easy to be recommended, explain their prices plainly, and give every new customer a reason to come back in January.




